Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jim Riggle's avatar

One of the best, most important, American books ever is, "The First New Nation," by the late, great Marty Lipset. Lipset notes several important characteristics. We're nontraditional, no titles of nobility. We have a comparatively weak, limited state. In principle, we're egalitarian. Most important for that lying coward, draft dodging sex criminal, would-be dictator Trump, the US was born in revolution. Screw that ignorant clown Trump.

Eric Goldman's avatar

Every one of these portraits is familiar to me, and not in the abstract.

I grew up under apartheid. The regime had its versions of all six of these people — the soldier who wouldn't stay quiet, the scientist who refused to disengage, the ones who'd lived under tyranny before and recognized the early signs, the officer who saw what deploying force against your own people really meant. They existed. They spoke. And here's the part worth saying plainly to anyone heartened by these stories: it works, but not quickly, and not for free.

The people who stood up in South Africa were detained, surveilled, fired, banned, some of them killed. I was beaten for saying no. But vindication came years later, when apartheid was overthrown. So when Navratilova says she's seeing the same signs, believe her. She's not being dramatic. She's reading the room with the only instrument that actually calibrates it: having been in the room before.

The hopeful truth and the hard truth are the same truth. Standing up is what breaks the machine — Matthews is right that the silence of cowardice is a choice. But it's a choice that costs the brave first and rewards them last. That these people are making it anyway, before the vindication, is exactly why it matters.

I wrote about watching this pattern arrive in America — "America, the Bell Tolls for Thee," an ex-South African's perspective on the new American apartheid, if it's useful: https://erictelltales.substack.com/p/america-the-bell-tolls-for-thee

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?