
By Paul C. LeBlanc
In January, a new Congress will take office with both the authority and the political opening to examine how the Department of Defense operates. The midterms shifted control of both chambers. What matters now is not which party holds the gavel, but whether the armed services committees use it for oversight or for show. The most urgent questions are quiet ones:
Whether commanders trust the legal advice they receive, whether leaders at all levels can offer unwelcome assessments without fear for their careers, and whether service members believe the rules apply equally throughout the chain of command.
It would be a mistake to treat repair as a project that begins with the next president in January 2029. Professional habits eroded in recent years will not snap back with a change in administration. Nor should Congress wait for a change in party control of the White House to insist on lawful, effective military governance. Its constitutional responsibilities exist now.
The concern is not hypothetical. On the night of January 24, 2025, the president fired at least 17 inspectors general across the federal government, including those in the Defense Department. Four weeks later, on February 21, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth removed the top uniformed lawyers of the Army and Air Force and announced plans to seek new Judge Advocates General for all three military departments. No performance-related reason was given.
Senior officers have been relieved before, but Pentagon leaders have customarily explained why. This time, the Secretary offered only this characterization: The lawyers had been “roadblocks to orders that are given by a commander in chief.” That phrase captures the misunderstanding at the heart of the issue. Law is not an obstacle to military readiness. It is part of what enables readiness.
Recently, Hegseth tweeted “Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS” in response to a video of Secretary of State Marco Rubio denouncing the International Criminal Court. It’s difficult to imagine a statement more openly contemptuous of the rule of law and the principle that the United States is a nation of laws, not men. Hegseth might reflect on the fate of Pompey, the Roman general whose words he echoes. Pompey discovered too late that swords cannot sustain what the rule of law is meant to preserve.
Military operations depend on decisions made under extraordinary pressure. Commanders need accurate intelligence, clear authority, disciplined forces, and subordinates willing to flag a bad plan before it becomes a catastrophe. A lawyer who explains that a proposed action exceeds legal authority is not interfering with the mission. That lawyer is helping the commander choose a course that can be executed, defended, and sustained. None of this means lawyers should command troops. Civilian leaders set policy. Commanders make operational decisions within lawful orders. Military lawyers advise on legal boundaries. The system works when each participant understands both the authority and the limits of their role.
That division of responsibility can erode without anyone formally rewriting the rules. If professional advice is treated as disloyalty, advisers begin to self-censor. If promotions reward agreement over judgment, leaders learn to tell superiors what they want to hear. If investigations are perceived as selective, discipline loses credibility. The consequences do not stay confined to headquarters. They travel down the chain of command.
Congress saw this risk coming. Since 2004, federal law has barred Defense Department officials from interfering with a Judge Advocate General’s ability to provide independent legal advice. The Inspector General Act requires the president to give Congress 30 days’ notice and a substantive explanation before removing an inspector general. These protections are meant to ensure that officials who tell leaders hard truths cannot be quietly removed for doing so. Statutes like these mean little if Congress fails to enforce them.
The new Congress has the tools to do so and should use three of them right away.
First, sustained, targeted oversight. Rather than staging hearings that yield more political theater than information, the armed services committees should call the removed officials and their successors to ask how senior military and legal advice now reaches civilian decisionmakers, what safeguards protect candid dissent, and whether established processes for promotions, removals, and investigations are followed. When classified details prevent public discussion, oversight can still occur behind closed doors.
Second, strengthen existing protections. Congress should use the annual defense authorization bill to require that the removal of a Judge Advocate General, as with an inspector general, be preceded by written reasons delivered to the armed services committees. It should fund inspectors general, military judges, defense counsel, and investigators at levels that allow them to do their jobs, and it should insist that the Military Whistleblower Protection Act provide meaningful protection against retaliation, not merely a form to file. These are the mechanisms by which an organization discovers its errors before they become scandals or operational failures.
Third, treat personnel decisions as a readiness issue. Senior officers and experienced civilians possess knowledge that no new organizational chart can replace. Congress need not second-guess every selection, but it should direct the Government Accountability Office to review promotion, removal, and investigation practices since January 2025, and report on whether established procedures were followed. Accountability and civilian control are compatible with fair processes, and such processes make legitimate civilian decisions more durable.
None of this requires insulating the military from elected leadership. The Constitution deliberately places the armed forces under civilian control. Presidents and defense secretaries are entitled to set policy, set priorities, and demand results. But civilian control is not the same as personal loyalty, and professional candor is not insubordination. A strong military can faithfully execute lawful policy while telling its leaders the truth about the risks.
These obligations are not the responsibility of any single party. A Congress that uses its new power only to embarrass an administration will squander the credibility that real oversight requires. A Congress that looks away would do even worse. The test for the incoming committee chairs is whether, two years from now, the institutions that keep the Pentagon lawful are stronger than they were when the new Congress arrived.
Whoever takes office in 2029 should arrive with a plan more substantial than a list of officials to replace. That work will be far easier if Congress has spent the intervening two years preserving these institutions.
There will be disagreement over defense priorities, and there should be. Americans can debate force structure, overseas commitments, spending, and strategy without accepting a military in which the rule of law is optional or professional judgment is a political liability. Those are the foundations on which competing policies must rest.
The measure of institutional repair will not be the number of speeches about constitutional values. It will be what happens the next time an officer, inspector, or lawyer raises a serious objection and the answer is inconvenient. That work begins in January by insisting that military effectiveness and the rule of law are not competing goals. They are inseparable.
Paul C. LeBlanc is a retired Navy judge advocate, a combat veteran, and a member of Veterans for Responsible Leadership. He lives in San Diego. The views expressed here are those of the author and Veterans for Responsible Leadership.



This should be in the INbox of every Congressperson.
Whoever takes office in 2029 will have a miserable amount of firing to do.
These last 2 years have seen only trump loyalists taking these federal jobs, replacing people with knowledge and experience with their yes - men and women who are there for just one reason, to further trumps agenda (that the entire USA rejected soundly at the mid-terms).
No one likes their cruel agenda or policies or the fact that they've stopped or made impossible to get, essential government services to people who really need them. Elderly and poor people are going to go hungry just so the wealthy get to stay wealthy. Yuck. They dance around to the music of YMCA and yet strip organizations just like the YMCA of critical federal funding. If it didn't hurt people, it would be funny because its so ridiculously hypocritical.
His agenda is lining his family's pockets with American tax dollars. It is embarrassing how badly he's abused the role of the Presidency, and yes, we've let them do this. They've "owned the libs" for the cost of destroying our beautiful free country, and turning it into this current dystopia everyone hates.
It's going to take a while to get rid of them all, but I really have faith in the millennials. They need to seize all of his assets the moment he leaves office or dies. All assets, everywhere in the world. The world hates him, so I am quite sure we'll find nations willing to testify to his theft and grift. We can inject that 4 billion toward taking our own eternal deficit down.
International law is only a "joke" or a "farce" to those boys because they are terrified of it coming to get them. And it better. I can't wait to see Hegseth answer for his crimes against humanity, he'll be peeing down his leg in submission. Life isn't a video game Petey, Marco or Stephen, you don't get to die and come back to life to fight again.